Bishops warn that UK is no longer Christian
(updated Jan 06)
  

British Christian leaders, Catholic & Protestant, have been voicing their concerns about the decline of Christianity and obliquely referring to the growing influence of other religions. What they don't do is to honestly examine the causes of the Christian decline and their own failure. It might open a can of worms.

 

Scottish Cardinal Keith O’Brien in a BBC Radio interview broadcast on (Sunday, 15Jan06) called on Scotland to be ‘re-christianised’. He recalled the conversion of Scotland by St Ninian who landed at Whithorn in 397 AD but added that the country no longer lived up to Christian standards. “I feel I must take a stand when Christianity itself is questioned in this country. I would certainly respect the beliefs of people of other faiths and acknowledge their feats just as they do when we celebrate Christmas and such feasts.  But I would also like them to realise that the are living in Scotland as a Christian country. Scotland was multi-cultural but the core faith in Scotland I would maintain is Christianity.”

 

The Head of the Scottish Episcopal Church, Rev Bruce Cameron, added: “As Christians, we are committed to the core task of Christian mission and sharing faith. Part of that is dialogue with other faiths.”

 

Asian reactions

A Hindu temple spokesman reminded the Cardinal: “If you go to India, there are more Christians there than in Britain. They have total autonomy and freedom of worship. The suggestion that Scoland should be re-Christianised is quite offensive.”

Osama Saeed, Scottish spokesman for the Muslim Association of GB thought the Cardinal’s remarks unsurprising: “When he talks about Christianising Scotland, he is going to the time when it was Christian and acknowledging that fact that that has been lost.”

Inyat Bunglwala, member of the Muslim Council of Britain, said: “O’Brien should be addressing his comments to Christians. Muslims are surprised that many Christians don’t take their faith seriously. O’Brien needs to look at his own flock and ask why they are not following Christianity, rather an get impatience with other faiths.”

Mohamed Sarwar MP (Glasgow Central) told the Scotsman: “When he says that people should learn to live in a Christian way, I don’t know what that means. It’s very ambiguous. People should be allowed to practise religion the way they want to.”

Jan 2006: Scottish Cardinal Keith O'Brien declared on BBC Radio: " the country no longer lived up to Christian standards..."

Jan 2003:  Cardinal Murphy-OConnor said in a Daily Telegraph interview, 'Britain has become a pagan country over the past half century in which people believe anything & everything... Christianity as a culture has gravely diminished...'

This is at least the second time he has referred to the failure of Christianity in Britain.

Sept 2001: He declared that Christianity is close to being 'vanquished' in Britain and no longer influences people's lives.

October 2000: Protestant Archbishop Carey had said that 'Britain is a society of atheists...tacit atheism prevails... only the old and the resigned retain their membership.' 

April 1990: Your predecessor, Cardinal Basil Hume, said: "Society appears to have abandoned fundamental aspects of Christian morality... We can no longer claim to be a truly Christian society. Society is getting increasingly insensitive and hard ... selfishness has been glamourised.'
Also in 1990, Archbishop of Canterbury, Runcie, said: "
This is not a decent society to live in ... greed and self-interest are the driving forces of our society... education is seen mainly as a commodity in the market place."
--------------------------------------
On 26 January 2003, Eddie D'Sa wrote to Cardinal Murphy-O'Connor under the heading 'Britain - a pagan country' and reminded him what senior clerics have been saying.
He also forwarded proposals on reform in an Appendix.
 
The letter concluded:
It seems then that church leaders agree that Christianity has failed in Britain (over the last 50 years at least) but amazingly no cleric admits blame. When an institution fails, the leaders have to bear responsibility for the failure and it is standard practice for them to resign in good grace and humility. So why don't they resign and clear the way for some kind of grand inquiry into the causes?  
Further, the cumbersome structures erected to sustain power must be dismantled. The missionaries sent overseas to convert the 'pagans' need to be recalled and a fresh programme launched to re-envangelise the (now pagan) mother country.
Evidently, the failed clerics must stay well clear of any attempts to reform the church, which in fact may be irreformable in its present form.
 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPENDIX - some pointers towards reform
 
1. The church has always been cosy with the ruling classes. That ensures its survival. The establishment feels safe that it will never be prophetically denounced for monumental state injustices at home & abroad, only chided in feeble platitudes.
 
2. The church has failed to challenge corporate capitalism and its neo-liberal doctrine that keeps enriching the rich at the expense of the poor. Europe is awash with prosperity while patently unfair trade policies and Third World 'debt' continue to keep a billion other people hungry. Some 20,000 Third World children daily.
 
3. The church authorities do not take racism seriously - even though the Holy Father has declared it a mortal sin. They seemingly can only relate to minorities within Anglocentric structures of domination and control. The senior clerics remain aloof, secretive and inaccessible to ordinary parishioners, taking decisions behind closed doors. 
 
4. The Black Catholic Charter (1990) favoured "a theology born out of and drawn from the peoples' experience, not just academic (but) a theology that takes account of other faiths and theologies."

Vatican documents are heavily Eurocentric and dryly academic but are deemed to have universal validity for all societies.

5. The Western World must urgently be re-evangelized...it has reverted to paganism and hedonism. poeple outside Europe strain to move away from the Western moorings towards an inculturated local church but the Rome-based leadership is determined to retain its stranglehold.

6. The issues of growing world poverty need to be addressed. Jesus came to serve the poor. The marginalization of the poor nations from the new global economy (the giants are mostly the "Christian" countries) is the very opposite of Jesus' invitation to the poor.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's the Cardinal's reply sent on 28 January 03.

Dear Mr. D'Sa,
 
Thank you for your letter.  It is true that I have indicated on various occasions that Christianity has been gravely diminished as a strong force in our society today. 
 
However, this has never meant that Christian people, i.e. the Churches, have not a task to do to evangelise this country and, indeed the challenge is even greater in view of the secularisation that has taken place. 
 
A culture or society can alter for a great number of reasons, which is not necessarily the fault of individual Christians.  Throughout history, the Church evangelises within different cultures and within different societies and will continue to do so, not least within our own country.
 
With kind wishes,
 
Yours sincerely,
 +Cormac Murphy-O'Connor

Archbishop of Westminster
Archbishop's House, Ambrosden Avenue
London SW1P 1QJ

Tel:            (020) 7798 9033,  Fax:            (020) 7798 9077
Email:          Archbishop@rcdow.org.uk
Website:        http://www.rcdow.org.uk

(END)